The recent announcement that scientists have made human-monkey embryos and cultured them in the lab for two weeks made international headlines.
The technology to make animals that contain cells from other species has been available for decades and used extensively in research. These organisms are called chimeras.
But this latest advance highlights the need to broaden the discussion around the possible benefits of such research and, specifically, how inter-species chimeric research should be conducted in future.
Human-animal chimeras blur the line about what it means to be human, and this raises serious ethical questions about how we should use them.
Human-monkey chimeras were first made in 2019. Inter-species chimeras are made by mixing cells belonging to one species with those of another.
This usually involves conducting microsurgery to introduce pluripotent stem cells which can develop into several different types of cells into a host embryo from another species.
In the recent study, human stem cells were placed inside six-day-old monkey embryos created by fertilisation. The human-monkey embryos comprised mostly of monkey cells and some human cells.
These embryos were then kept in a laboratory, where researchers monitored the interactions between the human and monkey cells for up to 14 days, although most embryos didnt survive.
Some will find the idea of mixing human cells with any animal embryo (let alone a primate embryo) highly questionable. For the researchers who led the study, the rationale was clear.
They were interested in addressing the shortage of life-saving organs for human transplantation. If done successfully, a chimera could grow an organ suitable for direct transplant into a human.
Researchers have previously created human-pig chimeras, where pig embryos containing human cells were allowed to grow into a foetus.
However, the contribution of human cells was low and the goal to create transplantable organs remained elusive. The question of how to solve this challenge is what led to the recent experiment.
Read more: What's the benefit in making human-animal hybrids?
In this recent study, researchers werent attempting to create human-monkey chimeras with a view to harvest organs. Rather, they created an in-vitro model (outside a living organism) to explore what happens to the transferred human cells.
They wanted to identify ways to enhance the survival of the human cells and ultimately improve human chimerism in pigs and other evolutionarily-distant species, with a view to developing transplantable human organs from animal donors.
This project might conjure images of mad scientists (think Victor Frankenstein) meddling with nature, irresponsible and without oversight. But unlike Frankensteins experiments, this study was not done in secret.
In the paper, the researchers describe in detail the steps they took to comply with international guidelines. This included extensive ethics reviews undertaken within the institutions involved and consultation with external bioethicists.
Of note, the study involved the use of eggs harvested from female monkeys. While the animals werent killed, any use of non-human primates should be approached conservatively and be consistent with international standards.
Research involving non-human primates is carefully scrutinised. Such projects receive special consideration from regulatory bodies and ethics committees around the world.
Nonetheless, even when conducted with ample oversight, human-animal chimera research does raise ethical questions.
The thorniest ones are linked not to the creation of in-vitro chimeric embryos, but rather the eventual creation of live-born chimeras, such as a human-pig chimera, if future research can overcome current limitations.
Read more: Fully-grown pig chimeras are only a few years away we need to understand where they stand now
Humans are widely (but not universally) thought to have a higher moral status than other animals. But human-animal chimeras blur this line. They are not fully human, nor fully non-human.
So the big question is whether (or under what conditions) we should be allowed to use them as a source of transplantable organs, in harmful research, or for other purposes we wouldnt use humans for.
These concerns will be most acute for chimeras with human-like brains, wherein human cells are incorporated into an animals brain during development.
Humans pride themselves on their autonomy, rationality and sophisticated self-awareness. If a human-pig chimera developed this capacity, it may have a moral claim to be treated more like a human than a pig.
The study raises a second ethical concern that is more immediately relevant. Using recent advances in monkey-embryo culture, the researchers cultured some embryos until 19 days post-fertilisation.
Many jurisdictions explicitly limit human embryo research to the first 14 days of development, when what will become the central nervous system begins to develop.
Should the 14-day limit also apply to human-animal chimeric embryos?
Perhaps it should depend on the proportion of human cells in developing chimeric embryo. Although, this leaves us with the question of how many human cells is too many.
Or perhaps, as some have argued, the 14-day rule ought to be revised.
Like many other aspects of stem cell research, we can find a starting point in guidelines from the International Society for Stem Cell Research.
These standards, soon to be updated, explicitly recommend specialised review for human-animal chimera research. This includes monitoring chimeric animals for unexpected behaviours that indicate suffering, which could then be addressed under existing animal ethics principles.
Experts say it might be worth monitoring chimeric animals for evidence they may be autonomous, rational, or self-aware and modifying their treatment accordingly.
Given the ethical complexity and sensitivity of human-animal chimera research, its crucial it receives careful oversight. As the field develops we must continuously review where the boundaries of the research lie.
And these conversations must not only explore animal welfare, but also how potential patients and the broader community view access to organs derived from donor animals.
Originally posted here:
- John Cleese says he's been spending 17,000 annually on stem cell therapy to 'buy a few extra years' - Yahoo News UK - April 24th, 2024
- Promethera Bets Liver-Derived Stem Cells Will Offer Benefits In NASH - Scrip - April 24th, 2024
- Stem Cell Therapies: Is This The Future Of Wellness? - Grazia USA - April 20th, 2024
- Signal of Benefit for Stem Cell Therapy in Progressive MS - Medscape - March 7th, 2024
- The Controversies Surrounding Stem Cell Therapy for Autism - The Portugal News - February 24th, 2024
- Benefits of Stem Cell Therapy - News Channel 5 Nashville - February 7th, 2024
- What is Stem Cell Therapy & How It Helps Others - Publicist Paper - January 31st, 2024
- A guide to stem cell therapy in Thailand - Thaiger - January 4th, 2024
- Half of pediatric patients with aHUS benefit from Soliris after... - AHUS News - December 21st, 2023
- Real world analysis on the determinants of survival in primary ... - Nature.com - December 5th, 2023
- The Best Beauty Gifts According To People Who Really Know Skin Care - HuffPost - December 5th, 2023
- The Eyepopping Factory Construction Boom in the US - WOLF STREET - December 3rd, 2023
- Benefit of Neoadjuvant Therapy Illustrated During ESMO Congress ... - Targeted Oncology - December 1st, 2023
- Benefits Outweigh Risks as FDA Inspects CAR-T Cell Therapy ... - Curetoday.com - December 1st, 2023
- Review What Real Cavityn Customers Say About Benefits and Side ... - Seattle Weekly - December 1st, 2023
- 'There is a Scientific Fraud Epidemic' - Slashdot - Slashdot - December 1st, 2023
- 15 Best Hydrating Serums to Soothe Any Skin Type 2023 - Town & Country - December 1st, 2023
- Innovations in Cosmetic Dermatology: A Glimpse into the Future - APN News - December 1st, 2023
- FDA Probes New Cases of Cancer That May Stem From Cancer Cell ... - MedCity News - November 29th, 2023
- Use of plant stem cells in topical formulations on the rise - CosmeticsDesign.com USA - November 29th, 2023
- Stem cell-based treatment controls blood sugar in people with Type ... - EurekAlert - November 29th, 2023
- Biologics Market is projected to grow at a CAGR of 8.5% by 2034: Visiongain - Yahoo Finance - November 29th, 2023
- Scientists devise new technique that can pinpoint the causes and ... - EurekAlert - November 29th, 2023
- Global Advanced Therapy Medicinal Products Market is on the brink ... - PharmiWeb.com - November 29th, 2023
- Introducing Orgavalue - The 2023 EIT InnoStars Awards winner - EU-Startups - November 29th, 2023
- Episode 160: Euan Ashley discusses precision medicine and the ... - IHMC - November 29th, 2023
- Is Phenq Right For You? Review The Facts Before Making a ... - Vashon-Maury Island Beachcomber - November 27th, 2023
- Cavityn Reviews - Does It Work? Cheap Scam or Effective ... - The Daily World - November 25th, 2023
- Trend Hunting With Beautystreams At Cosmoprof Asia 2023 - BeautyMatter - November 25th, 2023
- FDA Considers First CRISPR Gene Editing Treatment That May ... - Slashdot - November 25th, 2023
- How Do Plants Determine Where the Light Is Coming From? - Lab Manager Magazine - November 25th, 2023
- Deaths From Coal Pollution Have Dropped, But Emissions May be ... - Slashdot - November 25th, 2023
- Stem cell-based therapies for stroke in newborns - Cochrane - November 23rd, 2023
- Dr Leslie on Outpatient CAR T-Cell Therapy Programs for ... - OncLive - November 23rd, 2023
- Human Milk-Based Therapy May Be Beneficial in Blood Cancers - Curetoday.com - November 23rd, 2023
- Oncological Horizons: The Synergy of Medical and Surgical ... - Cureus - November 23rd, 2023
- Human and environmental safety of carbon nanotubes across their ... - Nature.com - November 23rd, 2023
- Immix Biopharma to Host KOL Event to Discuss its BCMA-Targeted ... - BioSpace - November 23rd, 2023
- #HearTheMarsdenKids call on NHS London to reconsider cancer ... - Metro.co.uk - November 23rd, 2023
- Diagnosis and Management of Cardiovascular Risk in Patients with ... - Dove Medical Press - November 23rd, 2023
- BioLineRx Reports Third Quarter 2023 Financial Results and ... - PR Newswire - November 21st, 2023
- Why our Award Winners Beauty Box is the ultimate beauty gift (for ... - Yahoo Singapore News - November 21st, 2023
- SightCare Reviews - Is Official Website for Sight Care Legit to Try or ... - Vashon-Maury Island Beachcomber - November 21st, 2023
- Legend Biotech Reports Third Quarter 2023 Results and Recent ... - StreetInsider.com - November 21st, 2023
- Lorenzo's Oil: Can It Really Treat ALD? - Verywell Health - November 19th, 2023
- Doctor Says Living To 120 By End Of Decade Is Possible What's the Secret? - Benzinga - November 19th, 2023
- The week in pharma: action, reaction and insight week to ... - The Pharma Letter - November 19th, 2023
- Race Cannot Be Used To Predict Heart Disease, Scientists Say ... - Slashdot - November 19th, 2023
- SpaceX's Starship Reaches Outer Space Before Intentional ... - Slashdot - November 19th, 2023
- Mesenchymal Stem Cells Market is projected to reach USD 3,319 million by 2030 according to a new research r... - WhaTech Technology and Markets News - November 17th, 2023
- LMRUK: Protecting the next generation through cord blood - Charity Today News - November 17th, 2023
- Anti-aging molecule discovered that extends lifespan - Earth.com - November 17th, 2023
- Montana State researcher envisions living building materials that ... - Montana State University - November 17th, 2023
- OxyHelp Explores the Benefits of Hyperbaric Oxygen Therapy for ... - StreetInsider.com - November 15th, 2023
- Health benefits of bone marrow - Pakistan Observer - November 15th, 2023
- Evolving the standard of care: What is next for functional ... - NeuroNews International - November 15th, 2023
- Affimed Reports Third Quarter 2023 Financial Results and ... - BioSpace - November 15th, 2023
- Meet the World's First Whole-Eye Transplant Recipient - TIME - November 15th, 2023
- Calidi Biotherapeutics Reports Third Quarter 2023 Operating and ... - Business Wire - November 15th, 2023
- 10 Asia-Pacific biotech companies leading innovation in the region - Labiotech.eu - November 15th, 2023
- Fitspresso Reviews (November Update) Natural Ingredients That ... - Bainbridge Island Review - November 15th, 2023
- 2seventy bio Reports Third Quarter Financial Results and Recent ... - Business Wire - November 15th, 2023
- Japan To Create $6.6 Billion Fund To Develop Outer Space Industry ... - Slashdot - November 15th, 2023
- Be The Match, Healthcare Marketing Impact Awards 2023 - Ad Age - November 13th, 2023
- Medicare coverage saves lives. Enrolling shouldn't be this ... - Kevin MD - November 13th, 2023
- Future Ocean Foods: 36 Global Alt-Seafood Startups Form Association To Tackle Overfishing, Microplastics & More - Green Queen Media - November 13th, 2023
- Orchard Therapeutics Reports Third Quarter 2023 Financial Results ... - StreetInsider.com - November 13th, 2023
- Celebrity doctor reveals Hollywoods hidden trend of stem cell antiaging therapies - Longevity.Technology - November 11th, 2023
- Amazon Expands Healthcare Push With One Medical Benefits For ... - Slashdot - November 11th, 2023
- Bene Meat Technologies becomes the first to receive EU approval ... - Pet Food Processing - November 11th, 2023
- FDA Grants Orphan Drug Designation to MAIA Biotechnology for THIO as a Treatment for Glioblastoma - Yahoo Finance - November 11th, 2023
- MaaT Pharma Provides Third Quarter 2023 Business Update and ... - Business Wire - November 11th, 2023
- IN8bio Reports Third Quarter 2023 Financial Results and Provides ... - GlobeNewswire - November 11th, 2023
- Fast Lean Pro Reviews - Overpriced or Optimal Ingredients That ... - Journal of the San Juan Islands - November 11th, 2023
- Fate Therapeutics Reports Third Quarter 2023 Financial Results and ... - GlobeNewswire - November 11th, 2023
- Worlds first whole-eye and partial face transplant gives Arkansas man new hope - CNN - November 9th, 2023
- Glowing Fingertips And Green Eyes: First-of-Its-Kind Monkey ... - ScienceAlert - November 9th, 2023
- 10 Natural Body Scrubs That Exfoliate And Invigorate My Skin - PINKVILLA - November 9th, 2023
- CRISPR Therapeutics Provides Business Update and Reports Third ... - StreetInsider.com - November 9th, 2023
- Fate Therapeutics Reports Third Quarter 2023 Financial Results and ... - StreetInsider.com - November 9th, 2023
Recent Comments