Questions about whether the Johnson & Johnson COVID-19 vaccine is morally acceptable to observant Catholics due to concerns over use of fetal stem cells in its development have brought the deep divisions within the Catholic Church into public view.
On Feb. 26, the Roman Catholic Archdiocese of New Orleans released a statement saying that the Johnson & Johnson vaccine is morally compromised as it uses the abortion-derived cell line in development and production of the vaccine as well as the testing. Four days later, the United States Conference of Catholic Bishops, the national body of Catholic bishops, stated, if one has the ability to choose a vaccine, Pfizer or Modernas vaccines should be chosen over Johnson & Johnsons.
A few days later, Kevin Rhoades, one of the bishops who issued the statement, attempted to clarify things when he said, Theres no moral need to turn down a vaccine, including the Johnson & Johnson vaccine, which is morally acceptable to use. But only hours later, the bishop of Bismarck, North Dakota, said the Johnson & Johnson vaccine is morally compromised and therefore [it is] unacceptable for any Catholic physician or health care worker to dispense and for any Catholic to receive due to its direct connection to the intrinsically evil act of abortion.
These statements have confused many Catholics and others outside the church, too. They have also led to concerns over people being discouraged from getting vaccinated.
As a political scientist who also works in theology, I have studied Americas growing political polarization, especially related to the Catholic Church, for many years. The current controversy about vaccines needs to be seen in that context.
Abortions and fetal tissue
To be clear, none of the vaccines directly uses fetal tissue. Embryonic stem cells can turn into any type of cell and are often used in medical research. Embryonic stem cells used in medical research are usually clones, thousands of generations removed from the original cell. Researchers can turn these cloned cells into any type of cell. All vaccines, whether Moderna, Pfizer or Johnson & Johnson, rely on stem cells, harvested decades ago from early stage aborted fetuses, for the laboratory testing of vaccines. This research is extensively regulated.
The Johnson & Johnson vaccine is somewhat different from the other vaccines because stem cells were used not only to test the vaccine in the lab, but also to produce it. Johnson & Johnson said in a statement recently: Several types of cell lines created decades ago using fetal tissue exist and are widely used in medical manufacturing but the cells in them today are clones of the early cells, not the original tissue.
However, Catholic moral theology obliges believers to be concerned that they might benefit from the abortions that resulted in those initial fetal stem cells.
Catholic moral theology
Faithful Catholics feel morally bound by the teaching of the Catholic Church that abortion is an intrinsic moral evil an act which never can have a justification.
The moral principle involved is called cooperation in evil. To understand cooperation, we might imagine the getaway driver in a bank robbery. The driver might not actually rob the bank or even approve of the robbery. Yet, driving the robbers away assures the robberys success. The driver has cooperated.
Cooperation can take many shapes. If I discover that a bank robber has used stolen money to buy me an expensive gift, I have profited from the robbery if I keep the gift and do not report the robber to authorities.
This example is a little more like the case of fetal stem cells. To accept a benefit from what is deemed an evil act even at some remote distance can be to cooperate with it in some situations.
Rarely are our moral choices so clear as these examples, however. It is shockingly easy to cooperate in evil in the course of daily life. Catholic moral principles can often help Catholics weigh and balance competing moral priorities.
Because the benefit obtained from stem cells that resulted from an abortion is a little bit more direct in the case of Johnson & Johnsons vaccine, Catholics have been more hesitant.
Pope Francis and many Catholic bishops have said people have a moral obligation to take the COVID-19 vaccine.
Still, weighing and balancing everything that is at stake, most Catholic bioethicists, many Catholic bishops and Pope Francis have found that receiving any of the vaccines is morally acceptable, which was the judgment of the Pontifical Academy for Life, a Vatican office that studies bioethical issues.
But there have been prominent Catholic bishops and other Catholic voices who have said that the Johnson & Johnson vaccine may not be administered by, or received by, a Catholic.
Divisions in church
The popular image of the Catholic Church is that it is a top-down organization, one unified voice with one central authority. It is this sensibility that gives rise to media headlines about the Catholic Churchs moral concerns over the Johnson & Johnson vaccine.
In one dimension, this is an accurate description of the church, which is a monarchy and does have one central authority in Rome. But in reality, the Catholic Church is more complex and much more fragmented than those outside often can see.
Jurisdictional distinctions are important in Catholicism. The Catholic Church is both a global institution and a highly local one.
The Catholic Church divides the globe into dioceses. Each diocese is overseen by a bishop who is the authoritative pastor and teacher of doctrine for his own diocese.
Catholic bishops enjoy a tremendous amount of autonomy inside their own dioceses. All of them are subject to the authority of the pope. But none of them is bound by anything another bishop says. Not even the United States Conference of Catholic Bishops has authority over any individual bishop.
The statement from the Archdiocese of New Orleans is binding only on Catholics in New Orleans. So is the case with the statements from bishops of Lexington and San Diego they have authority only within their diocese. The United States Conference of Catholic Bishops statement is intended to give guidance to Catholics around the United States, but has no particular authority over any individual Catholic.
Heres what the pope has said
To understand what is happening around the vaccine, context is important. Prior to recent decades, public disagreements among senior Catholic Church leaders like these were unheard of.
But public airings of pointed disagreements have been becoming more and more common over the last 25 years. In 2020, bishops were divided over how to deal with a Biden presidency. And this year, that division reemerged following an Inauguration Day statement from the United States Conference of Catholic Bishops that described how the Biden administrations policies could advance moral evils and threaten human life and dignity. Several church leaders later expressed public criticism over the statement. Such disagreements are a symptom of the polarization that is roiling the world all around the Catholic Church. This polarization is dividing Catholics, too.
Caught in the middle of all of this are ordinary, faithful Catholics who simply want to do the right thing. For that, the advice of Pope Francis would be a good place to start. Pope Francis has said that the role of the church, its bishops and priests is to inform consciences, not replace them.
Catholic Theological Union is a member of the Association of Theological Schools. The ATS is a funding partner of The Conversation US.
- Cellino Biotech developing tech to help scale stem cell therapies - MedCity News - April 14th, 2021
- Global Induced Pluripotent Stem Cell (iPS Cell) Industry Report 2021: Methods of Commercializing iPSCs are Diverse and Continue to Expand -... - April 14th, 2021
- A Massive New Gene Editing Project Is Out to Crush Alzheimer's - Singularity Hub - April 14th, 2021
- eQcell Inc Announces the Appointment of Members of the Board of Directors - BioSpace - April 14th, 2021
- Researchers Receive Grant to Improve Cellular Therapies to Treat 'Incurable' Diseases - University of Arkansas Newswire - April 14th, 2021
- Lonza Celebrates 20th Anniversary of Nucleofector Cell Transfection Platform - Technology Networks - April 14th, 2021
- New consortium aims to accelerate development of stem cell-based therapies for Huntingtons disease - News-Medical.Net - April 10th, 2021
- Strengthening the Stem Cell Industry Through Better Regulation - The Regulatory Review - April 10th, 2021
- Global Induced Pluripotent Stem Cell (iPS Cell) Industry Report 2021: Research, Patents, Funding Events, Industry Partnerships, Biomedical... - April 10th, 2021
- Stem Cell Transplantation May Be Offered Less Often as a Treatment Option for Some Patients with Mantle Cell Lymphoma - Curetoday.com - April 10th, 2021
- Real-time imaging shines light on the coordination of neural stem cell activation - News-Medical.net - April 10th, 2021
- Searching for Molecular Targets in Myeloid Malignancies and Beyond - OncLive - April 10th, 2021
- Fitore Nutrition Launches Spectrum + to Better the Lives of Children With Autism - Influencive - April 10th, 2021
- Cancer Stem Cells Market By Size Estimation, Growth Rate, Regional Analysis With with the CAGR of 11.0% Over the Forecast Period. KSU | The Sentinel... - April 10th, 2021
- global market for regenerative medicines is predicted to grow at a CAGR of 13.99% over the forecast period of 2020-2030 - GlobeNewswire - April 10th, 2021
- Adipose Derived Stem Cell Therapy Market New Business Opportunities And Investment Research Report 2020-2027 | Coherent Market Insights KSU | The... - April 10th, 2021
- Celularity Announces Multiple Presentations at the American Association for Cancer Research (AACR) Annual Meeting 2021 - GlobeNewswire - April 10th, 2021
- New local publication and book-signing event - Bowling Green Daily News - April 6th, 2021
- Human blastocyst-like structures generated entirely from pluripotent stem cells. Shifting the paradigm of developmental biology? - ESHRE - April 3rd, 2021
- Comprehensive Report on Stem Cell Therapy Market 2021 | Size, Growth, Demand, Opportunities & Forecast To 2026 | Cellular Dynamics... - April 3rd, 2021
- New approach to CAR T gene therapy yields efficient and longer-lasting response against HIV - News-Medical.Net - April 3rd, 2021
- New research offers hope to women with POI - Austin Daily Herald - Austin Herald - April 3rd, 2021
- Stem Cell Therapy Market to Witness Strong Growth Over 2021-2027 | Key Manufacturers Overview- Osiris Therapeutics, NuVasive, Chiesi Pharmaceuticals,... - April 3rd, 2021
- The entelechy test: embryos and simbryos - BioNews - March 30th, 2021
- Multiple sclerosis: Recent research on causes and treatments - Medical News Today - March 30th, 2021
- Global Regenerative Medicine Conference, NCRM NICHE with Fujio Cup Quiz (FCQ), E-poster and Edogawa NICH - Times of India - March 30th, 2021
- Study: Anti-Inflammatory Therapies Could Reduce Heart Disease Risk in Elderly Patients With Clonal Hematopoiesis - Pharmacy Times - March 30th, 2021
- Can This New Electrophysiology Technology Boost Neurology Research? - Labiotech.eu - March 30th, 2021
- Stem Cell Characterization and Analysis ToolMarket Size, Share, Industry Analysis, Forecast and Global Research Report to 2027 - The Market Eagle - March 30th, 2021
- Researchers describe the systems that manage embryonic stem cells - Microbioz India - March 26th, 2021
- Cell therapy player Fate Therapeutics sees CSO and 12-year veteran Shoemaker retire - FierceBiotech - March 26th, 2021
- Stem cells - a mix of promise and hype - ABC News - March 26th, 2021
- Global Vaccine, Insulin and Stem Cell Market Research Report Covers, Future Trends, Past, Present Data and Deep Analysis 2020-2026 The Bisouv Network... - March 26th, 2021
- Stem cell therapy could help restore debilitating age-related muscle loss - News-Medical.Net - March 24th, 2021
- Cell Culture: Disrupting the Meat Industry - Open Access Government - March 24th, 2021
- Canine Stem Cell Therapy Market Research and New Developments 2021-2026 KSU | The Sentinel Newspaper - KSU | The Sentinel Newspaper - March 24th, 2021
- Two In-Space Production Applications and Calls for Proposals Announced - Genetic Engineering & Biotechnology News - March 24th, 2021
- Hematopoietic Stem Cell Transplantation (HSCT) Market 2020-2027 Onset of Advanced Technologies to Upsurge the Growth The Courier - The Courier - March 24th, 2021
- Trending News: Stem Cell Cartilage Regeneration Market New Research Report 2021 to 2027| Anika Therapeutics, Zimmer Biomet, BioTissue Technologies -... - March 24th, 2021
- Researchers Have Grown 'Human Embryos' From Skin Cells. Is It Ethical? - The Wire Science - March 20th, 2021
- Stem cell therapy could help bear recover from painful disease - FOX 35 Orlando - March 20th, 2021
- Adipose-derived Stem Cell Overview Market Trend, Growth, Size, Forecast, Key Players and Competitive Landscape Research Report by2027 The Courier -... - March 20th, 2021
- Scientists Grow Tear Gland Organoids That Can Actually Cry - Freethink - March 20th, 2021
- Rheumatoid Arthritis Stem Cell Therapy Market Predicted to Witness Surge in the Near Future 2018 to 2028 KSU | The Sentinel Newspaper - KSU | The... - March 18th, 2021
- Catholic opinions on Johnson & Johnson vaccine highlight debate between hardliners on abortion and others in the church - Fairfield Citizen - March 18th, 2021
- Original Error: Retracing the History of the Mutation That Gave Rise to Cancer Decades Later - SciTechDaily - March 11th, 2021
- Super-resolution system microscopy can reveal pluripotency and differentiation of live stem cells - News-Medical.net - March 11th, 2021
- New multi-faculty Centre for Cell Therapy Translation gives UCalgary skin in the game for regenerative medicine research - UCalgary News - March 11th, 2021
- Policymakers urged to extend the 14-day limit on embryo research - BioNews - March 11th, 2021
- The Sacramento Business Journal announced that Cate Dyer, CEO, and founder of StemExpress, has been selected as one of SBJ's 2021 Most Admired CEOs -... - March 11th, 2021
- Coronavirus Insights: Ongoing Updates Covering The Impact On Induced Pluripotent Stem Cell Market - The Courier - March 11th, 2021
- Longeveron and University of Miami Expand Exclusive License Agreement, and Enter into CRADA To Facilitate Future Collaborations - GlobeNewswire - March 11th, 2021
- Adipose Stem Cells (ASCS) Market 2021 Global Analysis and Outlook: LifeCell, EMD Millipore, Geron, BrainStorm Cell Therapeutics, Minerva... - March 11th, 2021
- Stem cells: Therapy, controversy, and research - March 5th, 2021
- Human embryo research beyond the primitive streak - Science - March 5th, 2021
- Research Antibodies Market Size to Reach USD 5325.8 Million by 2027 | Increasing R&D Activities in the Fields of Oncology, Neurobiology, and Stem... - March 5th, 2021
- Stem Cell Therapy Market Research Reveals Enhanced Growth During The Forecast Period 2017 2025 FLA News - FLA News - March 5th, 2021
- Astrocytes Derived from Patients with Bipolar Disorder Malfunction - UC San Diego Health - March 5th, 2021
- Global Stem Cell Therapy Market Booming Market To Hit $ 18.66 Billion By 2027 With Top Key Players Osiris Therapeutics, Inc. (US), MEDIPOST Co., Ltd.... - March 5th, 2021
- Stem Cell Derived Exosome Production in Stirred-Tank Bioreactors - BioProcess Insider - March 5th, 2021
- Researchers study iPSCs to uncover genetic causes of disease - Drug Target Review - March 5th, 2021
- Moderna Hires Harvard Stem Cell Researcher Jonathan Hoggatt as Director of Hematology: What You Need to Know - Benzinga - March 5th, 2021
- Intrapericardial injection provides a less invasive means of treating cardiac injury - News-Medical.Net - March 5th, 2021
- Individualized brain cell grafts reverse Parkinson's symptoms in monkeys - University of Wisconsin-Madison - March 3rd, 2021
- New Controversy for Stem Cell Therapy That Repairs Spinal Cords - The Great Courses Daily News - March 3rd, 2021
- Cell Therapy Company Raises $160 Million to Advance iPSC-Derived Therapies to Clinic - BioSpace - March 3rd, 2021
- NSAIDs to Treat Arthritic Canines Through 2028; Stem Cell Therapies to Invigorate Canine Arthritis T - PharmiWeb.com - March 3rd, 2021
- A region within GLI1 gene could potentially be targeted as cancer treatment - News-Medical.Net - March 3rd, 2021
- Magenta Therapeutics Reports Fourth Quarter and Full-Year 2020 Financial Results and Recent Program Highlights - Galveston County Daily News - March 3rd, 2021
- Global Animal Stem Cell Therapy Market 2020 2025 Research Report Segment Outlook, Growth Potentials and Analysis of COVID-19 Worldwide Outbreak KSU... - March 3rd, 2021
- Global Autologous stem cell and Non-stem cell based Therapies Market- Industry Analysis, Growth, Segmentation and Forecast-2019-2027 - The Bisouv... - March 3rd, 2021
- Stem Cell manufacturing Market Witness an Outstanding Growth and Strong Revenue and Forecast 2027 KSU | The Sentinel Newspaper - KSU | The Sentinel... - March 3rd, 2021
- New study launches into COVID-19 vaccine responses in patients with impaired immune systems - University of Birmingham - March 3rd, 2021
- U. Cancer Center pilot projects: investigating cancer connections - The Brown Daily Herald - March 3rd, 2021
- Animal Stem Cell Therapy Market Size 2021 | Global Trends, Business Overview, Challenges, Opportunities and Forecast to 2027 The Bisouv Network - The... - March 1st, 2021
- Human Lung and Brain Organoids Respond Differently to SARS-CoV-2 Infection in Lab Tests - UC San Diego Health - March 1st, 2021
- Contemporary Critical Care Complications of Stem Cell Transplant/Cellular Therapies - TMC News - Texas Medical Center News - March 1st, 2021
- Global Human Embryonic Stem Cells Market Size-Share Analysis and System Production | Addressing the Potential Impact of COVID-19 Top Companies FLA... - February 21st, 2021
- Studies Show ApoE4 Carriers Appear More Susceptible to COVID-19Experts Say the Jury Is Still Out - Being Patient - February 21st, 2021
- Global Stem Cell Therapy Market 2020 | Demand and Scope with Outlook, Business Strategies, Challenges and Forecasts to 2025 KSU | The Sentinel... - February 19th, 2021