India just conducted its first successful experiment with savior sibling therapy, in which a baby was conceived through in-vitro fertilization for the purposes of donating bone marrow to an older ailing brother struggling with thalassemia, a condition characterized by low levels of hemoglobin in the blood that requires frequent blood transfusions. While the doctors involved in the therapy celebrated their success this week, some on social media challenged the ethics of such a therapy, in which a baby was essentially birthed to save her sibling.
In this case, the child with the genetic disorder needed a bone marrow transplant to cure his disease, and the chances of a successful cure are higher if coming from a person whose proteins (human leukocyte antigens, or HLA) exactly match those of the child. None of the childs existing family members was a match, further complicating the process of getting a bone marrow transplant an already difficult process to execute. The parents, in an effort to create a perfect bone marrow match for their child, underwent three cycles of in-vitro fertilization, out of which 18 embryos were created, and one perfectly matched that of the child, and was disease-free, using a technique called pre-implantation genetic diagnosis (PGD). The embryo was then implanted in the mothers uterus, carried to term, and a baby girl was born.
We had to wait for the baby to grow. She had to weigh 10 kg before we could draw bone marrow, Deepa Trivedi, program director of Sankalp Bone Marrow Unit in Ahmedabad, told The Hindu. Its been approximately seven months since the transplant, and the older sibling has not needed any more blood transfusions, indicating he has been cured of his thalassemia, his doctors announced.
Savior sibling therapy has already been used in countries such as the United Kingdom, the U.S.A., New Zealand, and France. Its mainly used to cure genetic blood disorders in children, such as sickle cell anemia or as seen in the Indian case, thalassemia major. The main way this is done, which is a departure from the Indian case, is by harvesting stem cells from a newborns umbilical cord, which are then injected into the bone marrow of the sibling with the disease, a practice that works 90% of the time. In case it doesnt, doctors can take bone marrow from the savior sibling as they grow, in a process that is painful but not known to be dangerous.
Related on The Swaddle:
Designer Babies Are Far From Reality, Even After the Gene-Edited Babies in China
The first ethical concern with this practice is treating a baby as a source for spare parts, as a means to an end, as a commodity. A study of the bioethics of savior sibling therapy, published in the Journal of Medical Ethics, surmised that treating a baby as a means to an end was not by itself a concern that devalued the utility of savior sibling therapy, as long as theyre also treated as human beings. Bioethicists surmise that using cord blood, something that is frequently discarded after birth, cannot endanger a newborn, or prove to be an ethical quandary used against the therapy.
But what has happened in the most recent case in India actually complicates the issue, because its not the umbilical cord blood that was harvested from the savior sibling at birth, but bone marrow 10 months into her life, which makes her an organ donor. This traverses thorny territory, as governments strictly regulate organ donation by minors due to issues related to consent. Can a baby consent to donating bone marrow to their sibling, or a 10-year-old consent to donating a kidney to their parent? It depends on where the individual resides, and how old the person being asked to donate is. In India, for example, it was only recently that the Delhi High Court ruled that minors could donate organs or tissues, as long as the procedure didnt pose a danger to their lives, and only in exceptional circumstances. However, where minors are mostly dependent upon their families, an element of coercion can also manifest. Also, determining whether a child rationally consented to donate an organ to their parent, for example, becomes difficult when we factor in the emotional element of their relationship that can perhaps override their judgments about their own safety.
Another concern is the well-being of the savior sibling throughout their life, both physical and psychological. Whats to stop a parent from asking the savior sibling to be on standby for their entire lives for their siblings health, available to be tapped for tissues and organs at any point in their lives? This is the plot of Jodi Picoults My Sisters Keeper (also turned into a film of the same name starring Cameron Diaz), but it is an unlikely scenario in real life, ethics experts have said. The aforementioned organ donation rules can prevent such an exploitative situation from arising, they say, with governments around the world tasked with ensuring the consent of the donor remains at the forefront of organ donation.
The third issue with savior sibling therapy arises out of the process itself if a parent can select an embryo that perfectly matches their child, whats to stop them from selecting an embryo for intelligence, or athleticism? This wades into the territory of the production of designer babies, which is an ethical slippery slope that critics have said goes against the natural reproductive order. However, the bioethics study asserts that the connection between savior sibling therapy and the production of designer babies is less of a slippery slope and more of a reach, as the technology might be similar, but the utility of both poles apart the former is used to save childrens lives, while the latter is a superficial, hypothetical fantasy.
For now, the world of savior sibling therapy, and its perception, remains similar to when parents first selected an embryo to create a savior sibling in the U.S. in 2000. As appeared in a New York Times article at the time, It is the kind of talk heard with every scientific breakthrough, from the first heart transplant to the first cloned sheep. We talk like this because we are both exhilarated and terrified by what we can do, and we wonder, with each step, whether we have gone too far. But though society may ask, How could you? the only question patients and families ask is, How could we not? 20 years later, savior sibling therapy still centers the children that can be saved, while government stipulations around the world try to ensure the savior siblings are protected, cared for, and treated as human beings, like any other child.
While a few critics argue for a ban, the bioethics study sums up the dilemma, and perhaps a solution to this ethical debate given that a ban will be fatal for a section of the population, the onus of proof rests clearly with the prohibitionists who must demonstrate that these childrens deaths are less terrible than the consequences of allowing this particular use of PGD.
You have got to have a very powerful reason to resist the means by which a childs life can be saved.
Originally posted here:
An Indian Baby 'Savior Sibling' Just Gave Her Brother Bone Marrow. But Is It Ethical? - The Swaddle
- One year to test 200 Cordlife samples 'totally unjustified': Global cord blood banking experts - The Straits Times - April 15th, 2024
- Clinical trial: First cardiac bioimplants for treatment of myocardial infarction using umbilical cord stem cells - Medical Xpress - April 7th, 2024
- The umbilical cord: a rich and ethical stem cell source to advance ... - March 30th, 2024
- Story of discovery: getting a Notch up on cord blood cell ... - March 30th, 2024
- Cord Blood Transplants | Memorial Sloan Kettering Cancer Center - March 30th, 2024
- Therapeutic effect and study of human umbilical cord blood mononuclear cells in patients with ischaemic bowel ... - Nature.com - March 17th, 2024
- Global Cord Blood & Tissue Banking Industry Report 2024: The Vast Majority of the Global Cord Blood Market is Now ... - PR Newswire - March 15th, 2024
- Improving Transplant Outcomes and Cell Therapy Approaches - RegMedNet - March 9th, 2024
- The inhibition of ADAM17 in cord blood stem cell-derived CD16+ NK cells to enhance their cytotoxicity against acute ... - ScienceDirect.com - March 1st, 2024
- Beating Blood Cancer through Recycling - a Community crowdfunding project in Liverpool by Kate Williams - Crowdfunder UK - February 24th, 2024
- Cord Blood Registry (CBR ) by CooperSurgical and Fulgent Genetics Launch Innovative Genetic Testing - Investing.com Canada - February 9th, 2024
- Young cancer patient with 'no hope' of recovery saved by baby's umbilical cord - Study Finds - February 9th, 2024
- Global Cord Blood & Tissue Banking Industry Report 2024 - The Vast Majority of the Global Cord Blood Market is Now ... - ACROFAN - January 26th, 2024
- Finding the optimal combination of anticancer drug administration for the conditioning of cord blood transplantation - Medical Xpress - January 26th, 2024
- Cord Blood Banking Market Sales and Revenue Report 2023-2032 - WhaTech Technology and Markets News - January 26th, 2024
- Global Cord Blood & Tissue Banking Industry Report 2024 - The Vast Majority of the Global Cord Blood Market is Now ... - ACROFAN USA - January 24th, 2024
- Global Biobanking Market Size To Exceed USD 97.5 Billion By 2032 | CAGR of 5.8% - GlobeNewswire - January 24th, 2024
- The use of cryopreservation in life saving research - The Manufacturer - January 24th, 2024
- CD19-targeted CAR NK cell therapy achieves promising one-year results in patients with B-cell malignancies - Medical Xpress - January 18th, 2024
- Cord blood banking comes at a high cost to babies - STAT - STAT - January 18th, 2024
- Global Cord Blood and Tissue Banking Industry Gains Traction Amidst Surging M&A Activity and Technological Advances - PR Newswire - January 16th, 2024
- Donating Bone Marrow and Stem Cells: The Process and What To Expect - On Cancer - Memorial Sloan Kettering - January 11th, 2024
- Ask the doctors: Research being conducted on using stem cells to treat diabetes - The Spokesman Review - January 4th, 2024
- askST: Can cord blood units be transferred from one bank to another? - The Straits Times - December 27th, 2023
- Timeline: Cordlife's mishandling of cord blood units in Singapore - CNA - December 15th, 2023
- Next-Level Evolution: Enhancing the Human Body With Anthrobots ... - Securities.io - December 5th, 2023
- Fred Hutch at ASH: Gene therapies for sickle cell, how to improve ... - Fred Hutchinson Cancer Center - December 5th, 2023
- Enhancing the immunosuppressive properties of human umbilical ... - Phys.org - December 1st, 2023
- Global Status and Trends for Thromboangiitis Obliterans | JPR - Dove Medical Press - December 1st, 2023
- Early Stage Cell Therapy Trial Shows Promise in Treating Progressive Multiple Sclerosis - University of Colorado Anschutz Medical Campus - December 1st, 2023
- Global Medical Specialty Bag Market is Expected to Reach US$ 9.4 Billion by 2034, Rising at a Steady 4.7% CAGR | Future Market Insights, Inc. - Yahoo... - November 29th, 2023
- Repeated concussions can alter heart activity and impact the heart ... - Philippine Canadian Inquirer - November 29th, 2023
- Vita 34 increases revenue and earnings in Q3 2023 and further ... - PharmiWeb.com - November 27th, 2023
- Vita 34 increases revenue and earnings in Q3 2023 and further ... - Marketscreener.com - November 25th, 2023
- FY 2021 VA-Funded Projects - VA's Office of Research and Development - November 25th, 2023
- New study aims to expand access to stem cell transplant using ... - Healio - November 23rd, 2023
- Impact of GVHD Prophylaxis on CMV Reactivation and Disease ... - Cancer Network - November 23rd, 2023
- The Top 25 Women Leaders in Biotechnology of 2023 - The Healthcare Technology Report. - November 21st, 2023
- First Edition: November 20, 2023 - KFF Health News - November 21st, 2023
- An essential guide to the building blocks of life - Gates Notes - November 21st, 2023
- A Simple Way to Save Premature Babies - The New York Times - November 19th, 2023
- Perspectives of current understanding and therapeutics of Diamond ... - Nature.com - November 17th, 2023
- Brain Organoids: Should They Be Considered People? - BBVA OpenMind - November 17th, 2023
- Understanding the cause of childhood Alzheimer's - ASBMB Today - November 17th, 2023
- Peripheral nerve regeneration through nanofiber scaffolds | IJN - Dove Medical Press - November 15th, 2023
- Are STEM CELL EXOSOMES the secret to a 'snatched' jawline? Discover the products that influencers are claiming - Daily Mail - November 13th, 2023
- CAR-NK: The next generation in hematological malignancy treatment - News-Medical.Net - November 13th, 2023
- Regenerative Medicine | Top Regenerative Medicine Solution ... - Healthcare Tech Outlook - November 13th, 2023
- Stem cell therapy, emerging solution to slow down ageing - Punch Newspapers - November 13th, 2023
- Improving Cord Blood Transplantation Outcomes for Adults With ... - On Cancer - Memorial Sloan Kettering - November 11th, 2023
- 8 Ways To Save Lives With Canadian Blood Services & You Can ... - Narcity Canada - November 11th, 2023
- Internal investigation by Vita 34 AG reveals irregularities related to a ... - Marketscreener.com - November 11th, 2023
- 'We worried the worst would happen' - Yorkshire Children's Trust ... - The Yorkshire Post - November 11th, 2023
- Minor GPI(-) granulocyte populations in aplastic anemia and healthy ... - Nature.com - November 9th, 2023
- Repeated treatment with ProTrans is immunologically safe ... - Marketscreener.com - November 7th, 2023
- Affimed Announces Oral Presentation of Phase 1/2 Data from AFM13 in Combination with Allogeneic NK Cells - Benzinga - November 7th, 2023
- Health Canada issues warning on cord blood stored in Edmonton - CBC News - November 3rd, 2023
- Affimed Announces Oral Presentation of Phase 1/2 Data from AFM13 in Combination with Allogeneic NK Cells at the 2023 ASH Annual Meeting - Yahoo... - November 3rd, 2023
- Dynamic Stem Cell Therapy Uncovers Research in Advance ... - InvestorsObserver - November 3rd, 2023
- Go with the flow and achieve hearing restoration - Drug Discovery News - November 3rd, 2023
- Cell Therapy Market to Witness Exponential Growth by 2031 ... - Argyle Report - November 1st, 2023
- Cross-talk between Myeloid and B Cells Shapes the Distinct ... - Cancer Discovery - November 1st, 2023
- Comparison of effects of HucMSCs, exosomes, and conditioned ... - Nature.com - October 28th, 2023
- The structural and functional complexity of the integrative ... - Science - October 28th, 2023
- Global Primary Cells Market to Witness Growth at 11.41% CAGR to ... - GlobeNewswire - October 26th, 2023
- Hma-Qubec celebrates 25 years of giving life in anniversary ad - - The Message - October 26th, 2023
- Improvement of thermal-stability of chondroitinase ABCI immobilized ... - Nature.com - October 26th, 2023
- Sydney Couple Overcomes Sperm Antibody Issue to Welcome Baby - OPP.Today - October 24th, 2023
- New Research Reveals Surprising Issue with Sperm and Fertility - CityLife - October 24th, 2023
- Biobanking Market to Observe Prominent CAGR of 6.10% by 2029 ... - PharmiWeb.com - October 21st, 2023
- TV shows like BBC's Call The Midwife and C4's One Born Every Minute 'are inaccurately depicting childbirth' an - Daily Mail - October 19th, 2023
- Advances in medical and technological research and SCI - Clyde & Co - October 18th, 2023
- Prognostic Value of Hematogones in Patients With Hematopoietic ... - Cureus - October 18th, 2023
- Stem-Cell Therapy: Filling Gaps in Oro-Maxillofacial Region - Cureus - October 18th, 2023
- The neonatal southern white rhinoceros ovary contains oogonia in ... - Nature.com - October 18th, 2023
- OMG: Sperm injury led to rare baby struggle - news.com.au - October 18th, 2023
- Experts Explain how MS Impacts the Eyes and Eye Health - Health Central - October 18th, 2023
- Newly identified stem cells can lure breast cancer to the spine - Science News Magazine - October 15th, 2023
- Cases of HIV cure | aidsmap - aidsmap - October 15th, 2023
- HokUS-10 scoring system predicts the treatment outcome for ... - Nature.com - October 13th, 2023
Recent Comments